Skip to content
5 min read

Website Copy: Why Yours Probably Isn't Working

Website Copy: Why Yours Probably Isn't Working

Your website looks fine. The brand is tidy, the photography is real, the navigation works on a phone. Traffic trickles in from Google. Nobody enquires.

Nine times out of ten, the copy is the problem. Not the design. Not the SEO setup. The words on the page.

Most website copy fails for the same reason: it's written for the company, not the buyer. The marketing team wrote what leadership wanted to say, signed it off, and shipped it. Nobody asked whether it answered the question a buyer actually has when they land on the page.

Here are five ways website copy quietly tanks your enquiry rate, with examples, plus what to write instead.

It opens with what you do instead of what your buyer is trying to fix

Land on the homepage of most service businesses and the hero says something like: "We are a leading provider of integrated business solutions across South East Queensland."

That sentence costs money. The person landing on that page is a business owner, an office manager or a marketing lead. They've got a problem to fix, a deadline to hit, or a budget to defend. They don't care that you're "leading." They want to know whether you can do the thing they need, in the timeframe they need it, at a quality their boss will sign off on.

What good looks like: "Mechanical services for commercial sites in South East Queensland. Plant rooms, chillers, BMS upgrades. We respond same-day." Same length. Buyer's problem first.

It uses category jargon your buyers don't search

Buyers are surprisingly literal in how they search. "Bookkeeper for tradies." "Commercial cleaning Ipswich." "Switchboard upgrade." "Small business accountant Springfield."

If your homepage says you provide "tailored end-to-end solutions for growing businesses" you've used six words to say nothing. None of those words are what a buyer types into Google, and none of them appear in a buyer's brief either.

Strip the abstraction out. Use the words your buyers use when they describe the work to their own boss. The keyword research almost always tells you the right phrase. The buyer is already telling you in the search bar.

It writes for every stage of the buying cycle on the same page

A homepage that opens with "Book a free consultation" assumes the visitor is ready to buy. Most aren't. Buying cycles for a considered purchase can run from as little as a few weeks to twelve months. The person on your homepage is usually scoping, comparing, or building a shortlist.

Copy that respects the buying cycle gives the early-stage visitor something useful, points the mid-stage visitor at evidence, and gives the late-stage visitor a clear next step. One CTA does not fit three different intents.

A practical fix: above the fold, state what you do and who you do it for. Mid-page, show recent projects with the client, the scope, and the outcome. Below the fold, give one clear CTA for buyers who are ready, and a soft offer (a guide, a checklist, a project gallery) for buyers who aren't.

It hides the proof

Most websites bury their best evidence. Case studies sit in a tab three clicks deep. Client logos appear in a faded grey strip in the footer. Testimonials live on a separate page nobody visits.

Buyers don't trust your homepage. They trust your other clients. If you've delivered work for a recognisable client in their sector, that logo belongs on the homepage near the fold, with the project named. If a client is happy to be quoted, that quote belongs on the service page that matches what they bought, not on a generic testimonials page.

Specific is what converts. "Reduced compressed-air leakage by 18% across three sites for [client]" beats "Trusted by industry leaders" every time.

It reads like a brochure, not a person

The fastest tell of weak copy is the voice. Passive sentences. Long paragraphs. Words like "deliver," "facilitate," "ensure." Capitalised job titles where they don't belong. The kind of writing nobody actually says out loud.

Read the page back to yourself in your speaking voice. If you wouldn't say it to a buyer in a meeting, don't put it on the website. "We facilitate financial clarity for small businesses" becomes "We help small business owners see where their money is going." Same meaning. Different planet.

Your website is read like a quote comparison, not a brochure

Here's the reframe that fixes most of it: Buyers don't read your website the way they read a magazine. They read it the way they compare quotes. They scan for the answer to a specific question, in a specific order. Can these people do the thing? Have they done it before? For someone like me? What's the risk if I bring them in?

Your copy needs to answer those four questions, in that order, on the page. If a buyer can't find the answer inside fifteen seconds, they close the tab and move to the next name on their shortlist. Nobody enquires from a website just to "find out more."

How to rewrite your website copy so people enquire

Work through these in order:

  1. Write down the four questions above. Walk through your homepage, your top service page, and your contact page. Mark every paragraph that answers one of them. Cut anything that doesn't.
  2. Rewrite the hero. Open with the buyer's problem and your specific capability. Use the words a buyer would use, not the words your category uses. One sentence is enough.
  3. Move the proof up. Pull two or three named projects onto the homepage with the client, the scope, and the outcome. If you can't share the client name, share the sector and the number e.g. "$180k office fit-out, professional services, completed in six weeks". This is an example of the format to use, not a claim about real work
  4. Match the CTA to the stage. One primary CTA for buyers who are ready, one soft offer for buyers who aren't. Stop forcing every visitor down the same funnel.
  5. Read it out loud. If a sentence sounds like a brochure or a LinkedIn bio, rewrite it in plain speaking voice.

Most of this is an afternoon's work for a service page and a few hours for a homepage. The lift in enquiry rate from doing it properly is usually larger than anything an SEO or paid campaign delivers in the same window, because every other channel pushes traffic at the page that's currently leaking it.

Jonathon Shipton

About author

Jonathon Shipton

Jonathon Shipton is a freelance digital marketing consultant in Brisbane. He specialises in search engine optimisation (SEO) and HubSpot website migrations.