Most businesses choose an SEO consultant the way they choose a restaurant: whoever looks good on page one. Six months later they're locked into a retainer with no movement in rankings and no clear idea of what's being done.
This guide shows you how to choose an SEO consultant before you sign anything. You'll get a weighted scorecard, pass/fail criteria, the questions to ask, the red flags that should end the conversation, and the consumer law and privacy checks that apply here.
A structured evaluation protects you in an unregulated industry
SEO consulting has no accreditation body, no minimum qualification and no standard scope of work. Anyone can call themselves an SEO consultant, so the due diligence sits with you.
The wrong consultant can burn 12 months of budget on tactics that never suited your market. A comparison framework makes every provider answer the same questions against the same criteria, so you're comparing like with like.
Step 1: define what you actually need
Get clear on what you're buying before you compare anyone. SEO consulting usually falls into a few categories, and most providers are stronger in some than others.
-
Technical SEO covers site architecture, crawlability, page speed, indexation and structured data. If your website has migration debt, duplicate content or a messy URL structure, start here.
-
Content strategy and production means keyword research tied to buyer intent, content planning, and writing that ranks and converts. It needs to go deeper than "blog posts about industry trends". Look for content mapped to the questions your buyers ask at each stage of their decision.
-
Local and national visibility matters if you serve specific areas. A consultant chasing national rankings for an online retailer is solving a different problem from one building local visibility for a Brisbane accounting firm.
-
HubSpot or CMS-specific SEO matters if your website runs on a platform with its own quirks. HubSpot CMS, WordPress and Webflow each have different technical SEO considerations. Some consultants specialise here. Most don't.
Write down your top 3 priorities and make them specific. "We need more leads" is too vague to brief anyone on. "We need to rank for 15 high-intent service keywords in Brisbane and turn that traffic into enquiries" gives a consultant something to plan against.
Step 2: build a weighted scorecard so you don't choose on gut feel
Give each criterion a weight (adding up to 100%) and score each provider from 1 to 5.
| Criterion | Weight | What you're measuring |
|---|---|---|
| Relevant industry experience | 20% | Have they worked with businesses like yours? Can they show results in your sector? |
| Technical SEO capability | 15% | Can they audit your site and explain the issues in plain language? Do they fix things or just report them? |
| Content strategy depth | 15% | Do they map content to buyer intent, or just chase volume? |
| Reporting and visibility | 15% | What do they report on, and how often? Can you see what they're doing month to month? |
| Commercial focus | 15% | Do they stop at rankings and traffic, or connect SEO to enquiries and revenue? |
| Team and capacity | 10% | Who does the work? Is it the person in the pitch, or someone you haven't met? |
| Contract flexibility | 10% | What's the minimum term? What happens if it isn't working? |
Score each provider after your evaluation calls and multiply each score by its weight. The totals give you a comparison you can defend to whoever signs off the budget.
Adjust the weights to match your priorities. If you're in the middle of a website migration, lift technical SEO capability to 25% and take the difference from elsewhere.
Step 3: set pass/fail criteria every consultant must meet
Some requirements shouldn't be traded off against a good score. Treat these as pass/fail.
-
Proven results in a business like yours. Ask for case studies or references from businesses similar to yours in size, sector or sales model. Ranking a SaaS product page takes a different approach from ranking a local service page. If they can't show relevant work, they'll be learning on your budget.
-
A clear methodology. They should be able to explain exactly what they'll do in the first 90 days. If the answer is vague ("we'll run an audit and develop a strategy"), press harder. What tools do they use? What does the audit cover? What will you receive?
-
A clear reporting cadence. Monthly reporting is the minimum. The report should cover rankings movement, organic traffic, leads from organic search and a summary of work completed. Reports built on impressions and "visibility scores" with nothing tied to business outcomes are a red flag.
-
No guaranteed rankings. Google's own guidance says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. A consultant who promises one is either misleading you or using tactics that put your site at risk. Walk away.
-
Local market knowledge. Search volumes here are far smaller than in the US or UK, and local search behaves differently. A consultant who has only worked in overseas markets will need time to learn that, and you'll pay for the lesson.
Step 4: ask questions that separate doers from sellers
These questions show you who does the work and who sells it and outsources the rest.
Experience and approach
- Which clients like us have you worked with in the last 2 years, and what were the measurable results?
- Walk me through the first 90 days of an engagement. What do we get, and when?
- How do you approach keyword research when search volumes in our market are low?
- What SEO tools do you use, and what access will we have to them?
Execution and reporting
- Who will do the work on our account? Can we meet them?
- What does your monthly report look like? Can we see a sample?
- How do you measure the commercial impact of SEO beyond rankings and traffic?
- Tell me about a strategy that didn't work as planned. What did you change?
- How do you work with in-house teams, and how much of our time will you need?
Terms and compliance
- What's the minimum contract term, and what's the exit process if it isn't working?
- Do you build links? If so, describe exactly how.
- Will you make changes to our website directly, or give recommendations for our team to implement?
- How do you handle data access and privacy in line with the Privacy Act?
AI and content
- Do you use AI to produce content? If so, how, and what's your quality control process?
- How do you make sure content meets Google's E-E-A-T standards (experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness)?
Listen to how they answer as well as what they say. Specific, detailed answers and an honest "I don't know" are good signs. Generalities and a rush to close are bad ones.
Red flags that should end the conversation
Some warning signs should rule a consultant out, however polished the pitch.
-
Vanity metrics. They talk about total organic traffic and never mention enquiries or conversion rates. That points to a consultant chasing easy wins.
-
A cookie-cutter proposal. If the strategy could apply to any company in any industry, it hasn't been built around your business and it won't perform like it was.
-
No failures to talk about. Every experienced consultant has had strategies fall flat. Someone who can't discuss what they learned from one either hasn't done much or won't be straight with you when things go wrong.
-
They can't explain their approach plainly. If you can't follow their plan in the pitch, you won't follow their reports either. SEO shouldn't be a black box.
-
They don't ask questions. A consultant who proposes a plan before asking about your customers, your competitors and what a lead is worth is more interested in closing the deal than solving your problem.
Step 5: run the ACCC and OAIC compliance checks most guides skip
The ACCC (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission) and the OAIC (Office of the Australian Information Commissioner) set rules that apply directly to how SEO consultants operate and what they can promise you.
ACCC: Australian Consumer Law
Under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010, businesses (SEO providers included) can't make false or misleading claims about their services. That covers:
-
Guaranteed rankings or traffic numbers. A guarantee of specific Google positions is likely to be a misleading claim under Australian Consumer Law, because no one controls Google's algorithm. Ask the consultant to put their performance claims in writing, then check whether they'd hold up as a reasonable representation of expected outcomes.
-
Testimonials and case studies. The ACCC requires testimonials to reflect genuine experiences and not mislead by omission. When a consultant shows you a case study, ask whether the results were typical, how long the engagement ran, and whether anything else (like paid advertising) contributed.
OAIC: the Privacy Act 1988 and the Australian Privacy Principles
If your consultant will access your Google Analytics, Search Console, CRM or any system holding personal data (and they almost certainly will), the Australian Privacy Principles apply.
Ask how they store and handle your data. Do they have a privacy policy that covers client data? Who on their team can see your analytics and CRM? What happens to your data when the engagement ends? Asking is part of your own due diligence under the Privacy Act, especially if your business holds customer data.
Compliance checklist
Run through these before you sign:
- Are their performance claims specific and reasonable, or do they guarantee outcomes they can't control?
- Do their case studies include context (timeframe, other contributing factors, whether results were typical)?
- Do they have a documented privacy policy covering client data?
- Have they told you who will access your systems and what data they'll collect?
- Does the contract say what happens to your data on termination?
- Are the contract terms clear, with no hidden auto-renewal clauses or unreasonable exit fees?
A provider who can't answer these clearly is telling you how they run their business.
Step 6: score, compare and set realistic expectations
Once the calls are done, fill in the scorecard for each provider, check each one against your pass/fail criteria and review their compliance answers. Then put all three side by side.
Your strongest option is the provider with the highest weighted score who also passes every baseline and compliance check. If two providers score close together, give the edge to the one with the higher reporting and commercial focus scores. Those two criteria decide whether you'll know the engagement is working 6 months from now.
Don't decide on price alone. The cheapest quote rarely delivers, and the most expensive one isn't automatically the best.
Agree on timeline expectations before you sign. Google's own list of questions to ask includes "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?" Get the answer in writing, and treat anyone promising page-one results within weeks with suspicion.
Ask for a 90-day review clause in the contract, too. Any decent SEO consultant will agree to a structured check-in against agreed KPIs. If they won't, that's your answer.
What to do next
Copy the scorecard above and adjust the weights to your priorities. Write your brief with the 3 specific things you need. Shortlist 3 to 5 providers and run each one through the scorecard, the questions and the compliance checks.
Want a second opinion on a shortlist or a proposal? Book a discovery call.
